The reason I joined the A3P (and I joined even before Kevin MacDonald was on board) had nothing to do with "wanting to be 3P." I joined because this was the first opportunity in my voting lifetime to join a group which explicitly promotes the interests of Whites AND which is structured to get on the ballot and participate in the mainstream national political process.
None of the groups you mentioned are/were positioned for ballot access.
I didn't care for the name at first, but it's grown on me. Their platform mostly matches up to my own ideals, but even if it didn't, I'd still join as long as the racial element was solid. I would just as quickly have joined the "Far Right Wing White Folk's Party" if it were a solid group structured to be a legitimate political party throughout the entire U.S.A.
None of the other groups believed much in voting or ballot access as a way to save our folk or even change america. Myself, I have long been anti- such measures. In 2008 however, I took a dive into the deep end. I joined up with the "Ron Paul revolution", most in our meetup even knew of my views on separatism and that I was pretty much a Third Position decentralist. I even had some good conversations about what it was and its history and even got into separatist issues as well.
I put every nickel I had into bumper stickers, t-shirts, signs, used every nickel I could spare to buy fliers and professional looking material for distribution, I went door to door distributing them and gave them out at work, put signs up all over our town and in towns surrounding ours, wrote letters to the editor to get attention to the campaign, bought RP's last book to give out to others and for the first time in my life actually gave every FRN I had to actually give to an official campaign. At the very last stage of the campaign, unlike Derek Black, I ran and actually got elected as a local Precinct Committeeman for the republican party. I kinda felt dirty doing it as I had long railed against both parties and being owned and controlled and being nothing but pressure release valves for the average citizen. Nonetheless, I ran and got elected. The duties of such though were nothing like I had wanted to be part of. It was selling tickets for the Lincoln Day republican party gatherings - King Lincoln of all people, a man who destroyed states rights and sovereignty. It was helping local yahoo's who were in no way revolutionaries, likely not racialist, and for the most part not even really die-hard Constitutonalists. In the end, I pretty much just stopped going to the events as it wasn't what I wanted to be involved in.
Ron Paul had so much support though that it was amazing. Most of his ideas were grounded in solid truth. Not 3P'ism by a long shot, but there were certainly many things that he supported that were very Third Position such as allowing for local and competing currencies and barter and trade and even allowing for distributism which has long been the economic platform of the Third Position.
If he and all of his support couldn't get someone elected to such a position what makes us think that we could?
Granted, since he lost it has taken on a life of its own with people running for local offices on the same or similar platforms. Recently this came to a head in Texas with the Debra Medina campaign being nearly identical to his. She lost as well. It has further made me realise the difference between Third Position/National Revolutionary ideologies and electioneering.
3P has pretty much came to the conclusion that victory won't be won by voting our way out of the mess. Instead of such, it has promoted timeless alternatives such as buying up land to run local co-ops and alternatives on, working with local and like-minded businesses, trying to start independent businesses and co-ops as a means of producing an income and not being a slave to the bosses, communities producing their own currencies (E.G. Ithaca Hours, River Hours etc) , folk centered charities, homeschooling alternatives or "folk schools", etc. Some groups such as the OLD American Front when they were 3P promoted this, Sigrdrifa (not sure whatever happened to them), Volksfront (at least on their website promoted ideas such as this) and other fledgling groups such as Folk And Faith, Neo-Political and other non-organisation websites promoting such alternatives.
A few links on true and Traditional Third Positionism might be of interest:
http://folkandfaith.com/articles/articles.shtmlhttp://www.folkandfaith.com/articles/community.shtmlVictoria wrote:
"I would just as quickly have joined the "Far Right Wing White Folk's Party" if it were a solid group structured to be a legitimate political party throughout the entire U.S.A."
No offense but I guess this is what irks me about them and others jumping onto the 3P name - that they really have no interest in 3position'ism.